Although “hipster” as a term will likely spring to mind the image of a heterosexual, chic, urban trendsetter, we here at the Tragically Unhip feel the need to clarify something: There is a new butch on the block, and that would be the Lesbian Hipster. Perhaps we can call this sub-species the lesbihipsteranius, and she, just like her straight counterparts, enjoys such convivial pastimes as sex and nightlife, preferably both at the same time. The club atmosphere in New York is indistinguishable for both hipsters and hipsterettes on the prowl for a hot, sweaty time in a bar that doesn’t close until 4am. But it is not that simple to achieve the ritual of self-marketing (or booty-shaking, as it were) and mate-selection in the Brooklyn/Manhattan lesbian club scene.
In typical Tragically Unhip list form, I bring you the breakdown of some of the most frequented clubs and parties held in the hipper boroughs of New York City, with commentary from personal experience both terrifying and amusing.
“GirlNation” at Nation, Saturdays — W. 45th Street, Manhattan
This was the first lesbian party I had ever been to and went there to celebrate my first job offer in New York. The crowd is mostly sporty and dressed in the familiar hues of American Eagle, Abercrombie, and Hollister, with a smattering or two of Gap and Banana Republic. GirlNation is a Saturdays-only party that begins at 10pm and has a $10 cover. Staff is surly and projects the feeling that they might spray you with the fountain soda of their choice just to show you who’s boss. Occasionally they get back to their Coyote Ugly roots and stomp a few boots on the bar, with a confetti of body shots thrown in for good measure.
What to Look For: The updated version of the cigar/cigarette girl; the jello shots; the roving whipped-cream-shot-in-your-mouth girl who will shamelessly follow you around begging you to spend money, and hounding you mercilessly when the bartenders tell her that you tip poorly.

Perennial hipster favorite at Metropolitan. (Photo by Laurin McNiff)
The Metropolitan, Wednesdays — 559 Lorimer, Williamsburg
If you like dive bars, Metropolitan is the archetype. The bathrooms are unisex and have no locks on them, so they require a spotter if you don’t enjoy having a gay man throw the door open and comment on the angle of your squat. No matter what time you walk in the door, it feels empty. This is because everyone has arrived at 10pm, grabbed a few $2 PBR’s and headed to the outdoor patio to establish a social stronghold on a coveted bench corner. It would take a real brave soul to come here alone in the hopes of cruising for someone single, as it is excruciatingly obvious that this is a bar to which you travel in packs. I have a general rule of never going to Metropolitan less than three girls deep—preferably four—otherwise you get that old lunchroom feeling where you have a tray full of cafeteria food and all the cool seats are taken. This is a social jungle and not for faint-of-heart clubgoers.
What to Look For: PBR’s for $2 until 4am (because part of being hip means you also must be cheap); people-watching and noting some of the best overheard one-liners imaginable; bringing your straight friends and not having to reassure them that they will need therapy once the night is over; watching various Billburgers drunk-cycling home (my personal favorite).
“Choice Cunts” at Sultana, last Saturday of every month — 160 N. 4th Street, Williamsburg
I discovered Choice Cunts during Pride 2008 amidst the frustration of repeated rain outs, Marco Polo-esque phone tag searches for friends, and discovering a make-out session every time I turned around. The cover is $15 per person and there is no a/c in the hookah bar-turned-lesbian haven. At first my compatriots and I shared a look of disdain and outright “we have arrived in Bad-idea-ville,” but we soldiered on. My first clue to its hipster quotient should have been when a photographer snapped a photo of me and my roommate, after which I queried “That’s not going on the internet is it?” as she ran away. This crowd was significantly different from the crowd at GirlNation. There were granny-glasses abound, too-tight 80’s jeans, street corner fedoras, faux-hawks, and, of course, old faithful: American Apparel t-shirts. This party is a competitive and completely hedonistic lesbian mecca.
What to Look For: The sheer amount of dry humping and consolidated make-out corners in just about every square foot; an overwhelming butch-to-femme ratio (so cock-blocking is inevitable); a dedicated, pleasant, and surprisingly audible DJ; no Pabst Blue Ribbon that I can remember.
“Secret Faggot” at Glasslands — Somewhere in Williamsburg
I’ll admit, I saved this one for last because I went there once directly from a party and have no recollection of its actual address due to the half dozen Wild Turkey shots I had ingested before going. My initial reaction was “The party is called Secret Faggot? I have to go just to confirm this.” The floor had that familiar sticky unknown-ness that your shoes never like, and within the first ten minutes of dancing to the beat, a complete stranger was sucking on my neck. The dress code seemed to be casual—if by casual I mean “must nap in a dumpster beforehand.”
What to Look For: Drunken hipster lesbians, everywhere; a total lack of sobriety; the girl who can hula-hoop for 20 minutes straight without losing momentum or spilling her drink.